Selective Insurance Group Stock Performance

SIGI Stock  USD 74.94  0.18  0.24%   
The company has a Beta (Market Sensitivity) of 0.5, which conveys generally lower market sensitivity than the broad market. Returns on Selective Insurance tend to trail the broader market in strong rallies but hold up better when sentiment turns negative. At this point, Selective Insurance has a negative expected return of -0.18%.
Risk-Adjusted Performance
Weak
 
Weak
 
Strong
For the recent 90-day horizon, Selective Insurance Group failed to convert risk into positive risk-adjusted performance. Used correctly, this score supports evaluation of raw price movement versus actual return efficiency. Despite latest unsteady performance, the stock's technical and fundamental indicators remain strong and the recent confusion on Wall Street may also be a sign of long-lasting gains for the firm's traders. Learn More

Actual Historical Performance (%)

 One Day Return
1.41
 Five Day Return
1.22
 Year To Date Return
-10.49
 Ten Year Return
109.94
 All Time Return
16.9 K
 Forward Dividend Yield
0.022
 Payout Ratio
0.2192
 Last Split Factor
2:1
 Forward Dividend Rate
1.62
 Dividend Date
2026-03-02
Begin Period Cash Flow63 M
Total Cashflows From Investing Activities-1.5 B

Relative Risk vs. Return Landscape

If you had invested $ 8,413 in Selective Insurance Group on December 27, 2025 and sold it today you would have lost $ 939.00 from holding Selective Insurance Group or given up 11.16% of portfolio value over 90 days. Selective Insurance Group does not currently generate positive expected returns and carries 1.3341% risk (volatility on return distribution) over a 90-day horizon. In different words, 11% of stocks are less volatile than Selective, and 99% of all traded equity instruments are projected to make higher returns than the company over the 90 days investment horizon.
  Expected Return   
       Risk  
This comparison focuses on expected return, realized volatility, and risk efficiency versus the market. It is most useful when expected return is read together with volatility rather than in isolation. Given the investment horizon of 90 days Selective Insurance is expected to under-perform the market. In addition to that, the company is 1.56 times more volatile than its market benchmark. It trades about -0.14 of its total potential returns per unit of risk. The Dow Jones Industrial is currently generating roughly -0.1 per unit of volatility.

Target Price Odds to finish over Current Price

Mean reversion in Selective Stock pricing reflects the documented tendency for stocks to gravitate toward equilibrium. While this pattern holds broadly, certain stocks can remain mispriced for extended periods before correction.
Current PriceHorizonTarget PriceOdds moving above the current price in 90 days
74.94 90 days 74.94
roughly 96.0
Using a normal distribution model, the likelihood of Selective Insurance moving above the current price in 90 days from now is roughly 96.0 . Past return patterns over this horizon reflect a distribution that has favored above-current-price scenarios. (The curve shows where outcomes have been clustering for Selective Stock over the next 90 days). The curve width gives a practical read on how much uncertainty surrounds Selective Stock over this horizon.
Given the investment horizon of 90 days Selective Insurance has a beta of 0.5. This usually implies as returns on the market go up, Selective Insurance's average returns are expected to increase less than the benchmark. However, during a bear market, the loss from holding Selective Insurance Group is expected to be smaller as well. Additionally, Selective Insurance Group has a negative alpha, implying that the risk taken by holding this instrument is not justified. The company is significantly underperforming the Dow Jones Industrial.
   Selective Insurance Price Density   
       Price  

Predictive Modules for Selective Insurance

Predicting the direction of Selective Insurance involves a range of quantitative and qualitative stock techniques. Each approach has strengths and limitations, making diversified forecasting strategies especially important for Selective Insurance.
Mean reversion is the tendency of Selective Insurance's price to return to its historical average after periods of extreme deviation. Some analysts monitor this tendency by comparing Selective Insurance's price extremes to fundamental value.
Hype
Prediction
LowEstimatedHigh
72.9674.2975.62
Details
Intrinsic
Valuation
LowRealHigh
67.2783.2784.60
Details
Naive
Forecast
LowNextHigh
75.8277.1578.49
Details
Analyst
Consensus
LowTargetHigh
80.4788.4398.16
Details
Competitive analysis for Selective Insurance compares its financial performance and valuation against sector peers. This relative perspective often changes investment conclusions drawn from standalone analysis.

Primary Risk Indicators

Over the past two decades, the stock market has experienced significant volatility affecting Selective Insurance. Selective Insurance has seen dramatic price moves that have reshaped risk profiles for its holders.
α
Alpha over Dow Jones
-0.1417
β
Beta against Dow Jones0.50
σ
Overall volatility
4.14
Ir
Information ratio -0.0789

Investor Alerts and Insights

Staying informed about Selective Insurance through targeted alerts gives investors the edge they need to evaluate market conditions and assess potential outcomes. These notifications for Selective Insurance help investors make timely decisions in response to significant stock events.
Selective Insurance generated a negative expected return over the last 90 days
Selective Insurance Group currently holds $898.3 M in liabilities with Debt to Equity (D/E) ratio of 0.19, which may suggest Selective Insurance is not taking enough advantage from borrowing. Selective Insurance has a current ratio of 0.32, indicating that it has a negative working capital and may not be able to pay financial obligations when due. Note, when we think about Selective Insurance's use of debt, we should always consider it together with its cash and equity.
Over 89.0% of the company shares are owned by institutional investors
On 2nd of March 2026 Selective Insurance paid $ 0.43 per share dividend to its current shareholders
Latest headline from finance.yahoo.com: Why The Narrative Around Selective Insurance Group Is Shifting On Mixed Analyst Signals

Price Density Drivers

Price movements in Selective Insurance are influenced by the balance of buyer and seller positioning dynamics. Monitoring key indicators provides context for understanding when price movements are fundamental versus tactical.
Common Stock Shares Outstanding61.1 M
Cash And Short Term Investments1.2 B

Selective Insurance Fundamentals Growth

The market price of Selective Stock is shaped by investors' expectations for Selective Insurance's financial performance. Revenue and earnings trends, operating margins, and capital structure decisions all play a role in Selective Stock pricing.

Performance Metrics & Calculation Methodology

Benchmark comparison for Selective Insurance clarifies whether returns reflect stock-specific outcomes or market-wide trends. Outperformance relative to the benchmark may reflect exposure tilt, selection effect, or timing. Selective Insurance shows ROE of 13.86%, ROA of 2.79%.

Inputs for Selective Insurance Group come from periodic company reporting and market reference feeds and are mapped into a consistent reporting framework. Some fields can appear with publication lag. Return and risk statistics are calculated from historical price series.

This content is curated and reviewed by:

Rifka Kats - Member of Macroaxis Editorial Board
Last reviewed on March 23rd, 2026